Draft Article 5A (Article 6) was debated on 10, 11 and 12 August 1949. It had not been included in the Draft Constitution 1948. It laid down the principles of citizenship with regard to persons who migrated from Pakistan to India after partition.
Some members proposed to add ‘on account of Civil disturbance or the fear of such disturbances’ in the first clause. It was argued that the inclusion of this phrase would articulate and make explicit the real intention behind this provision which was to facilitate migration from Pakistan in the wake of civil disturbance or fear of it.
Another member wanted to make it compulsory to provide evidence to prove right by descent and intention to permanently reside in India. He argued that Indian citizenship must be regarded as a matter of great privilege, and not a cheap or easy affair.
A member of the Drafting Committee reminded the Assembly that this Article sought to settle basic principles of citizenship, and did not aim to establish a ‘code of nationality law’, which were to be left to Parliament. One member went on to say that compared to the Indian constitution, no other constitution even made an attempt to comprehensively deal with various aspects of nationality law.
Towards the end of the debate, some members voluntarily withdrew their amendments, while other amendments were rejected. The Assembly adopted Draft Article 5A on 12 August 1949.
