Bangalore District Court
B.S. Rajamma vs R. Munegowda on 24 December, 2024
KABC020167262019
BEFORE THE CHIEF JUDGE, COURT OF SMALL
CAUSES, MEMBER PRL.MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS
TRIBUNAL AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 24th DAY OF DECEMBER, 2024
PRESENT : SRI J.N.SUBRAMANYA, B.A., L.L.M.,
MEMBER, PRL. M.A.C.T.
M.V.C.No.3860/2019
Petitioners: 1) Smt.B.S.Rajamma,
Aged about 44 years,
W/o.B.G.Papaiah.
Died on 23.09.2021
Since deceased represented by
Legal Representatives
1(a) Sri B.G.Papaiah,
Aged about 48 years,
S/o. Govindappa.
1(b) Kum. P.Dhanushree,
Aged about 21 years,
D/o. B.G.Papaiah.
1(c) Sri P.Srinivas,
Aged about 18 years,
S/o. B.G.Papaiah.
All are R/at No.545/1,
Dargajogihalli,
Doddaballapura Town,
Bangalore Rural District,
Bangalore -561 203.
SCCH-1 2 MVC No.3860/2019
(By Sri. Reeyazulla Shareef,
Advocate)
-Vs-
Respondents: 1. Sri R.Munegowda,
Major in age,
S/o. Ramaiah,
R/at Managondanahalli village,
Koira Post, Devanahalli Taluk,
Bangalore District.
(By Sri. K.N.Sathish Kumar,
Advocate)
2. The Regional Manger,
M/s.United India Insurance Co.Ltd.,
III Party Hub, 5th Floor,
Krushibhavan Buildings,
Bangalore.
(By Sri. D.N. Manjunatha Gupta,
Advocate)
JUDGMENT
On 05.07.2019 B.G.Papaiah asserting to be guardian
of his wife Smt.B.S.Rajamma, filed petition under Section
166 of IMV Act claiming compensation worth of
Rs.5,00,00,000/- from the respondents, who are the
owner and insurer of the motorcycle bearing No.KA-43-L-
6993 alleging that on 28.01.2019 at about 9.30 a.m. when
Smt. Rajamma about to cross Kodigehalli road, near
Muthyalamma temple, Doddaballapura town to reach
SCCH-1 3 MVC No.3860/2019
Anagalapura village , rider of motorcycle bearing No.KA-43-
L-6993 rode the same negligently, dashed the same to
Rajamma, thereby caused the accident, caused grievous
injuries to Rajamma.
2. Immediately after the accident Rajamma has been
shifted to Govt. hospital , Doddaballapura, then to
Columbia Asia Clinic at Doddaballapura, wherein first aid
has been provided , then admitted to Columbia Asia
Hospital, Yeshwanthpura, Medstar hospital , Kodigehalli,
Bengaluru, Basavashri Diagnostic Center and Reneu Life
Physiotherapy and Rehabilitation, Unit of Siddaganga
Healthcare Center at Nagarabhavi, Bengaluru for
treatment.
3. In view of the injuries suffered in the accident,
inspite of better treatment on 23.09.2021 Smt. Rajamma
expired.
4. As on the date of accident Rajamma, being aged 44
years , used to earn Rs.45,000/p.m. by working as Asst.
Teacher at Government Lower Primary School,
Anagalapura village, Doddaballapura taluk, used to
contribute the entire income to the family.
SCCH-1 4 MVC No.3860/2019
5. Regarding accident Doddaballapura Town police
registered crime No.10/2019 .
6. In response to the notice, respondent No. 1 owner
of the motorcycle appeared through his Advocate, but
neither filed written statement nor participated in the
proceedings.
7. In response to the notice, respondent No. 2
insurance company appeared through his Advocate on
26.09.2019 filed written statement denying the allegation
regarding reason, mode of accident, nature and
consequence of the injuries suffered by Rajamma, age
occupation and income of Rajamma.
8. On the basis of the pleadings on 04.11.2019, this
Authority has framed the following issues:
1. Whether the petitioner proves that she
sustained grievous injuries in a Motor Vehicle
Accident that occurred on 28.01.2019 at about
9.30 a.m. near Muthyalamma temple,
Kodigehalli road, Doddaballapura town, within
the jurisdiction of Doddaballapura Town police
station on account of rash and negligent riding
of the motorcycle bearing registration No.KA-
43-L-6993 by its rider when the petitioner was
about to cross the road?
SCCH-1 5 MVC No.3860/2019
2. Whether the respondent No.2 proves that the
accident has occurred on account of negligent
act of petitioner herself ?
3. Whether the petitioner is entitled for
compensation ? If so, how much and from
whom?
4. What order?
9. By get appointing the Court Commissioner, through
Court Commissioner B.G.Papaiah , husband of Smt.Rajamma
get recorded the evidence of Dr.N.Shobha as PW1 , get marked
3 documents at Ex.P.1 to P.3 on 03.02.2021 about the health
status of Smt.Rajamma.
10. As noted above on 23.09.2021 Smt.Rajamma
expired. Then by filing application under Order XXII Rule 3 of
CPC B.G.Papaiah , P.Dhanushree, P.Srinivas, husband and
children of deceased Rajamma, get impleaded as petitioner
No.1(a) to 1(c).
11. On 10.08.2023 respondent No.2 insurance company
filed additional written statement.
12. After amendment of the petition and filing of the
additional written statement by respondent No,2/insurance
SCCH-1 6 MVC No.3860/2019
company , on 14.08.2023 , this authority has framed the
following additional issues:
1. Whether the petitioners prove that the
deceased Petitioner died on 23.09.2021 on
account of accidental injuries and there is
nexus between accidental injuries and her
death?
13. On 24.08.2023, 25.06.2024 B.G.Papaiah deposed as
PW2 and produced 34 documents at Ex.P.4 to 37. On
26.02.2024, 28.03.2024, 03.07.2024 B.G.Papaiah produced
the evidence of Medical Record Officer of Columbia Asia
Hospital (now Manipal hospital), Bengaluru, Medstar
Speciality hospital , Kodigehalli, Bengaluru as PW3 to 5 and
get produced 10 documents at Ex.P.38 to P.47.
14. I heard the arguments submitted on behalf of
petitioners No.1(a) to (c) and respondent No.2 perused the
records.
15. On the basis of material on record, my findings
on the above issues are as under:
Issue No.1 … In the Affirmative,
Issue No.2 … In the Negative
Addl. Issue … In the affirmativeIssue No.3 … Petitioners No.1(a) to 1(c)are entitle
to receive Rs.85,99,510/- with interest
SCCH-1 7 MVC No.3860/2019at 6% p.a. from 23.09.2021 from the
respondents as compensation .
Issue No.4 … As per final order
for the following:-
REASONS
16. Issues No.1, 2 and additional issue :- In the
argument learned Advocate appearing for the respondent
No.2, by analyzing the evidence available in file, submitted
that there is no nexus between injuries and death of
Rajamma by relying on the following judgments:
1. ILR 2013 4519 (Divisional Manger, United India
Insurance Co.Ltd., Vs. Mallappa Basappa Indur, by his
Lrs and another) D.D.18.01.2013
2. ILR 2002 KAR 660 ( Baburao Sataba Manabutakar,
deceased by his Lrs Vs. Doreswamy and others) D.D.
04.09.2001.
3. ILR 1990 Kar 4300 ( Kannamma Vs. Deputy General
Manager) D.D. 27.11.1990
4. ILR 2002 KAR 1864 ( Uttam Kumar Vs. Madhav and
another) D.D. 27.03.2002
5. MFA No.1572/2008 ( Shri Hanamant and others Vs.
Shri Shankar Kedaraba Koli and another) D.D.
05.02.2015
6. ACJ 2008 page 191 ( H.S.Chetan (deceased) by Lrs Vs.
Chandra Mouli and another ) D.D. 12.04.2006
SCCH-1 8 MVC No.3860/2019
17. In the lengthy argument, learned Advocate
appearing for petitioners No.1(a) to (cc), by analyzing the
evidence available on file, requested to award reasonable
compensation and to impose the liability on the second
respondent .
18. In the light of the submission made on behalf of
both the parties with reference to the judgments cited
above, I have appreciated the materials on file.
19. In the evidence affidavit PW2 B.G.Papaiah ,
husband of deceased Rajamma stated that on 28.01.2019
at about 9.30 a.m. when Rajamma about to cross
Kodigehalli road, near Muthyalamma temple,
Doddaballapura town to reach Anagalapura village , rider
of motorcycle bearing No.KA-43-L-6993 rode the same
negligently, dashed the same to Rajamma, thereby caused
the accident, caused grievous injuries to Rajamma.
20. After accident Rajamma who has been shifted to
Govt. hospital , Doddaballapura, wherein first aid has been
provided , then shifted to Columbia Asia Clinic at
Doddaballapura, wherein further treatment has been
provided , then get treated Rajamma at Columbia Asia
SCCH-1 9 MVC No.3860/2019
Hospital, Yeshwanthpura, Medstar hospital , Kodigehalli,
Basavashri Diagnostic Center and Reneu Life
Physiotherapy and Rehabilitation, Unit of Siddaganga
Healthcare Center at Nagarabhavi, Bengaluru , Sri
Dharmasthala Manjunatheshwara Institute of Ayurveda
and hospital , Kumbalagodu , Bengaluru from 28.01.2019
to 15.02.2019, 15.02.2019 to 23.02.2019, 23.02.2019 to
04.09.2019, 24.01.2021 to 07.02.2021.
21. PW2 stated that in view of the injuries suffered in
the accident, inspite of better treatment, on 23.09.2021
Smt.B.S.Rajamma expired.
22. In the written statement and additional statement,
respondent No.2 insurance company denied the allegation
regarding reason, mode of accident, nature and
consequence of the injuries suffered by Rajamma and
reason for death of Rajamma.
23. In the cross-examination, PW2 B.G.Papaiah stated
he never witnessed the accident, after 3 days of the
accident, elder brother of Rajamma filed complaint at
Doddaballapura town police station. PW2 denied the
suggestion that even eventhough motorcycle bearing
SCCH-1 10 MVC No.3860/2019
No.KA-43-L-6993 never caused the accident, some other
vehicle caused the accident, only to claim compensation,
after 3 days get filed a false complaint.
24. In the evidence affidavit PW3 to 5 Medical Record
officer of Columbia Asia Hospital, Medstar hospital and
Manipal hospital have produced case sheet and other
documents at Ex.P.38 to P.47.
25. Ex.P.4 is the copy of the FIR pertaining to crime
No.10/2019 registered by Doddaballapura town police
against the rider of motorcycle bearing No.KA-43-L-6993
for having committed offence punishable under Section
279,337 of IPC r/w 187 of IMV Act regarding causing of
injuries to Rajamma by dashing motorcycle bearing No.KA-
43-L-6993 on 28.01.2019 at 9.30 hours on the basis of
complaint presented by Siddagangaiah S/o.
Siddabommaiah.
26. Ex.P.5 is the copy of the complaint, Ex.P.6 is the
copy of spot mahazar recorded on 31.01.2019 , Ex.P.7 is
the copy of the vehicle seizure mahazar recorded on
04.02.2019. Ex.P.8 is the Motor Vehicle Accident Report
recorded on 06.02.2019. Ex.P.9 is the copy of the wound
SCCH-1 11 MVC No.3860/2019
certificate issued by Columbia Asia Referral hospital ,
Yeshwanthpura in which reason for the injury suffered by
Rajamma is noted as RTA near Muthyalamma temple ,
Jalappa college road, Doddaballapura. Ex.P.10 are the
copy of the statements of Gangamuthaiah, S/o.
Kemparangaiah, Ramesh, S/o. Hombanna,
Channarayappa, S/o. Eraiah, Panduranga, P.C. 1559
recorded by Investigation officer.
27. Ex.P.11 is the copy of the chargesheet filed by
Doddaballapura town police in crime No.10/2019 against
Pradeep H.N., S/o. Narayanaswamy for having committed
offence punishable under Section 187 of IMV Act, Section
279,338 of IPC .
28. Medical records shows that in the accident
deceased Rajamma suffered grievous head injuries , took
treatment at Columbia Asia Hospital, Yeshwanthpur from
28.01.2019 to 15.02.2019, Medistar hospital, Kodigehall
from 15.02.2019 to 23.02.2019, Reneu Life Physiotherapy
and Rehabilitation, Unit of Siddaganga Healthcare Center
at Nagarabhavi, Bengaluru from 23.02.2019 to
04.09.2019, Sri Dharmasthala Manjunatheshwara
SCCH-1 12 MVC No.3860/2019
Institute of Ayurveda and hospital, Kumbalagodu ,
Bengaluru 24.01.2021 to 07.02.2021.
29. Ex.P.39 is the copy of Medico legal register issued
by Manipal hospital , Yeshwanthpur in which appearance
of Rajamma with the history of RTA injury to head , taken
treatment at local hospital is mentioned. Ex.P.40 is the
copy of the police intimation dated 28.01.2019 forwarded
by Columbia Asia Hospital , Yeshwanthpura to PSI,
Malleshwaram police station. Ex.P.46 is the copy of the
police intimation dated 28.01.2019 forwarded by Medical
Officer of Columbia Asia clinic, Doddaballapura intimating
bringing of Rajamma with the history of RTA to SHO ,
Rural police station, Doddaballapura.
30. Copy of UDR No.32/2021 shows that on
23.09.2021 at 11.00 a.m. on the basis of the
report/information provided by B.G.Papaiah about the
death of Rajamma , PSI/ police inspector , Doddaballapura
Circle registered UDR No.32/21 and forwarded the same to
Addl. Civil Judge, JMFC Court , Doddaballapura.
Enclosure of UDR No.32/2021 is the copy of the inquest
SCCH-1 13 MVC No.3860/2019
mahazar recorded on 23.09.2021 and P.M.Report dated
23.09.2021. Third enclosure of UDR No.32/2021 is the
report dated 23.09.2021 forwarded by Police Inspector,
Doddaballapura circle, to Medical Officer , Govt. hospital ,
Doddaballapura seeking opinion about the reason for the
death of Rajamma.
31. Fourth enclosure is the report dated 25.04.2022
forwarded by PSI , Doddaballapura Circle to Addl. Civil
Judge, JMFC, Doddaballapura seeking to insert Section
304(A) of IPC in crime No.10/2019 of Doddaballapura town
police station which is pending for adjudication and to
continue the trial. The other enclosure of UDR No.32/2021
are the chargesheet filed by P.I., Doddaballapura circle in
crime No.10/2019 against Pradeep H.N., S/o. Narayana
swamy for having committed offence punishable under
Section 279,304(A) of IPC , Section 187 of IMV Act.
32. In this case respondents have not produced any
type of evidence to disbelieve the contents of police records
and medical records produced by the petitioners regarding
reason , mode and consequence of the accident and about
the reason for the death of Rajamma.
SCCH-1 14 MVC No.3860/2019
33. Hence, I have concluded that on 28.01.2019 at
about 9.30 a.m. when Smt.Rajamma about to cross
Kodigehalli road, near Muthyalamma temple,
Doddaballapura town to reach Anagalapura village ,
Pradeep H.N., S/o. Narayanaswamy, negligently rode
motorcycle bearing No.KA-43-L-6993 dashed the same to
Rajamma,thereby aused accident resulting in the grievous
injuries, who has been treated in various hospitals,
however, inspite of better treatment on 23.09.2021
succumbed to those injuries. Hence, I answer issue No.1
and Addl. Issue in the affirmative and issue No.2 in the
negative.
34. Issue No.3: In the evidence affidavit PW2
Papaiah stated that as on the date of accident Rajamma
being aged about 44 years , used to earn Rs.45,000/p.m.
by working as Asst. Teacher , Government Lower Primary
School, Anagalapura village, Doddaballapura taluk, used
to contribute entire income to the family.
SCCH-1 15 MVC No.3860/2019
35. In the written statement respondent No.2
insurance company denied the allegation regarding age,
occupation and income of the deceased Rajamma.
36. In the cross-examination, PW2 denied the
suggestion that as on the date of accident, his wife is aged
more than 50 years and never used to earn Rs.45,000./-
p.m. PW2 stated that in the pay slip marked at Ex.P.27
and P.28 date of birth of his wife is noted as 06.06.1975.
37. Medical bills shows that from the time of
accident till 23.09.2021 PW2 get treated his wife Rajamma
at various hospitals by spending approximately
Rs.22,24,406/-.
38. Under certificates marked at Ex.P.31, B.E.O. ,
Doddaballapura certified that regarding the treatment
provided to Rajamma , medical reimbursement has not
been paid to PW2 Papaiah. Salary particulars marked at
Ex.P.27 and P.28 and other documents shows that as on
the date of incident Rajamma used to earn Rs.39,321/-
p.m. (Basic Rs.37.900/- + DA Rs.1421/-) by working as a
Asst. Teacher, Government Lower Primary School,
Anagalapura village, Doddaballapura taluk. Hence, I have
SCCH-1 16 MVC No.3860/2019
calculated compensation under the head of loss of
dependency in the following terms:
Age of the deceased Rajamma as on the 44 years
date of accident –
Monthly income of deceased Rajamma as on – Rs.39,321/-
the date of accident
Add: 30% towards future prospects Rs.51,117/-
(Rs.39,321+11,796= 51,117)
Less : 1/ 3rd towards personal expenses of Rs.34,078/-
the deceased Rajamma (51,117 – 17,039/-
= 34,078)
Annual income of the deceased 34,078×12 Rs.4,08,936/-
Multiplier Applicable 14
Loss of dependency 4,08,936×14 Rs.57,25,104/-
39. Hence, I award Rs.57,25,104/- towards loss of
dependency. Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate,
Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses , Rs.40,000/-
towards spousal consortium to petitioner No.1,
Rs.80,000/- towards parental consortium to petitioners
No.2 and 3 at the rate of Rs.40,000/- each, Rs.22,24,406/-
towards treatment charges, Rs.5,00,000/- towards
attendant, conveyance etc.,
40. As referred above, in this case compensation has
been calculated as if a death case i.e., Smt. Rajamma
SCCH-1 17 MVC No.3860/2019
expired on 23.09.2021. Hence, I came to the conclusion
that petitioners No.1(a) to (c) are entitle to receive
Rs.85,99,510/- with interest at 6% p.a.. from 23.09.2021
as compensation from the respondents.
Sl.No. Head of Compensation Amount/Rs
1. Loss of dependency 57,25,104-00
2. Loss of estate 15,000-00
3. Funeral expenses 15,000-00
4. Loss of Consortium to 1,20,000-00
petitioners No.1to3 at
Rs.40,000/each
5. Treatment charges 22,24,406-00
6. Attendant, conveyance etc. 5,00,000-00
Total 85,99,510-00
41. In the written statement respondent No.2
insurance company admitted the subsistence of the policy
with respect to motorcycle bearing No.KA-43-L-6993 as on
the date of accident . In the file there are no evidence to
show that respondent No.1 owner of the motorcycle bearing
No.KA-43-L-6993 has violated any terms of the policy.
Hence, I came to the conclusion that the respondents being
the owner and insurer of the motorcycle bearing No.KA-43-
SCCH-1 18 MVC No.3860/2019
L-6993 are liable to pay compensation and an award is to
be passed directing the respondents No.1 and 2 to pay
compensation to the petitioners, Hence, I answer issue
No.3 accordingly and pass the following :
ORDER
The petition filed by PW2 B.G.Papaiah , on behalf of
B.S.Rajamma on 05.07.2019 under Section 166 of IMV Act
claiming compensation on behalf of Rajamma and after
23.09.2021 , date of death of Rajamma continued by
B.G.Papaiah, P.Dhanushree, P. Srinivas is hereby partly
allowed.
The respondents No.1 and 2 being the owner and
insurer of motorcycle bearing No.KA-43-L-6993 shall either
jointly or severally pay Rs.85,99,510/- with interest at
the rate of 6% p.a., from 23.09.2021 to petitioners
towards compensation.
The respondent No.2, being the Insurer of the
motorcycle bearing No.KA-43-L-6993 shall deposit the
compensation amount with interest within 4 months from
today.
SCCH-1 19 MVC No.3860/2019
The compensation amount and interest are distributed
among petitioners equally .
After deposit of the compensation amount, entire
compensation amount and interest allotted in favour of
petitioners No.1(a) to 1(c) may be released by crediting the
same to their respective bank accounts directly.
Advocate’s fee is fixed at Rs.1,000/- .
Draw an Award accordingly.
(Dictated to the Stenographer, transcribed by her, corrected,
signed and then pronounced by me in the Open Court on this
the 24th day of December , 2024)
(J.N.SUBRAMANYA)
Chief Judge,
Court of Small Causes &
Member, Prl. M.A.C.T.
Bangalore.
ANNEXURES
Witnesses examined on behalf of the petitioners:
P.W.1 : Dr.N.Shobha dt. 03.02.2021, 05.02.2020
P.W.2 : B.G.Papaiah dt. 24.08.2023, 25.06.2024
P.W.3 : Priyanka A., dt. 26.02.2024
P.W.4 : Rajesh A. dt. 26.02.2024
P.W.5 : Rangarasaiah dt. 28.03.2024
SCCH-1 20 MVC No.3860/2019Documents marked on behalf of the petitioners:
Ex.P.1 Neuro psychological assessment report
dated 15.02.2020
Ex.P.2 Neuro Psychological assessment report
dated 09.11.2020
Ex.P.3 6 OPD follow up prescriptions
Ex.P.4 Certified copy of FIR
Ex.P.5 Certified copy of complaint
Ex.P.6 Certified copy of spot mahazar
Ex.P.7 Certified copy of seizure mahazar
Ex.P.8 Certified copy of IMV report
Ex.P.9 Certified copy of wound certificate
Ex.P.10 Certified copy of witness statements of
Gangamuthaiah , Ramesh,
Channarayappa, Panduranga PC 1559
(1 to 4 )Ex.P.11 Certified copy of chargesheet
Ex.P.12 Discharge summary issued by Columbia
Asia Hospital
Ex.P.13 Discharge summary issued by Medstar
Speciality hospitalEx.P.14 Discharge summary issued by Reneu
Life Physiotherapy and Rehabilitation
Center (2)Ex.P.15 Discharge summary issued by Sri
Dharmasthala Manjunatheshwara
Institute of Ayurveda and hospitalEx.P.16 Certified copy of FIR in UDR
No.32/2021Ex.P.17 Certified copy of complaint in UDR
No.32/2021Ex.P.18 Certified copy of Inquest report in UDR
No.32/2021
SCCH-1 21 MVC No.3860/2019Ex.P.19 Certified copy of FSL Report in UDR
No.32/2021 dated 01.12.2021 issued
by State Forensic Science Laboratory ,
Madivala , Bengaluru.
Ex.P.20 Certified copy of Histopathology Report
dated 23.09.2021 issued by
Department of Pathology , Victoria
hospital, Bangalore Medical College and
hospital, Bengaluru .
Ex.P.21 Certified copy of P.M.Report of
Smt.Rajamma in UDR No.32/2021Ex.P.22 Certified copy of request letter issued to
Medical officer, Government hospital ,
Doddaballapura from Police
Sub -Inspector , Doddaballapura Town
Police station.
Ex.P.23 Certified copy of Requisition forwarded
to JMFC Court, Doddaballapura to
seeking permission insert Section
304(A) and to proceed the investigation.
Ex.P.24 Certified copy of Requisition forwarded
to JMFC Court, to submit additional
chargesheet in crime No.10/2019Ex.P.25 Certified copy of of Final report
submitted to Magistrate ,
Doddaballapura in UDR No.32/2021
along with witness statementsEx.P.26 Certified copy of Additional chargesheet
with covering letterEx.P.27 Salary statement of the deceased from
December 2018 to November 2020Ex.P.28 Salary slips of the deceased from
SCCH-1 22 MVC No.3860/2019December 2018 (17)
Ex.P.29 Letter issued by BEO , dated
29.12.2020 regarding availment of E.L.Ex.P.30 Letter issued by BEO , Doddaballapura
dated 2904.2020 regarding sanction of
Medical leave without pay from
11.06.2019 to 16.01.2021Ex.P.31 Letter issued by BEO Doddaballapura
regarding non-reimbursement of
medical expensesEx.P.32 Bank statement issued by Union Bank
of India from 01.01.2019 to 31.03.2019Ex.P.33 to Notarized copies of aadhar cards of
35 petitioners No.1(a) to 1(c)Ex.P.36 Prescriptions (43)
Ex.P.37 Medical bills (389)
Ex.P.38 Authorization letter
Ex.P.39 Certified copy of MLC Register Extract
Ex.P.40 Certified copy of police intimation
Ex.P.41 Inpatient case sheet
Ex.P.42 X-ray with report
Ex.P.43 Autorization letter
Ex.P.44 Inpatient case sheet
Ex.P.45 Authorization letter
Ex.P.46 Certified copy of Police intimation
Ex.P.47 Patient advise and progress note
SCCH-1 23 MVC No.3860/2019Witnesses examined on behalf of the respondents :
-Nil-
Documents marked on behalf of the respondents:
-Nil-
(J.N.SUBRAMANYA)
Chief Judge,
Court of Small Causes &
Member, Prl. M.A.C.T.
Bangalore.