Introduction
Human rights and global governance serve as two vital interlinked pillars of the contemporary international order. Human rights represent the fundamental freedoms and protections intrinsic to every individual. At the same time, global governance mechanisms are increasingly upholding these rights, often extending beyond national borders. In today’s world, characterised by globalisation, urgent issues such as climate change, armed conflict, and economic disparity necessitate collective responses. Therefore, the role of international institutions in defending human rights becomes paramount.
This article examines the interplay between human rights and global governance. It scrutinises legal frameworks, enforcement mechanisms, ongoing challenges, and the engagement of sovereign states, with a particular focus on India’s role within this system.
I. The Foundations of Human Rights in Global Governance
1. The Evolution of International Human Rights Law
The contemporary human rights framework took shape after World War II, culminating in the adoption of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) in 1948. This seminal document, along with subsequent treaties, established a universal benchmark for civil, political, economic, social, and cultural rights. Key instruments in this framework include:
– The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR, 1966)
– The International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR, 1966)
– The Convention Against Torture (CAT, 1984)
– The Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW, 1979)
These treaties form the foundational elements of global human rights law, compelling signatory states to adhere to established standards within their jurisdictions.
2. The Role of Global Governance Institutions
Global governance denotes the collaborative management of transnational issues through international organizations, treaties, and norms. Significant institutions, such as the United Nations (UN), actively engage in protecting human rights. The UN serves as the principal platform for international human rights dialogue. Similarly, the UN Human Rights Council (UNHRC) monitors violations and conducts Universal Periodic Reviews (UPRs) of member states. The International Criminal Court (ICC) takes legal action against genocide, war crimes, and crimes against humanity, while the International Labour Organisation (ILO) safeguards labour rights and promotes fair working conditions.
However, despite these structures, enforcement often proves inconsistent. Concerns over state sovereignty, geopolitical rivalries, and institutional limitations impede effective action.
II. Challenges in Implementing Human Rights Through Global Governance
1. Sovereignty vs. Intervention
A significant tension arises between the principle of state sovereignty and the enforcement of international human rights. Numerous nations resist external oversight, asserting that human rights constitute a domestic concern. For instance, China dismisses UN critiques regarding its actions in Xinjiang and Tibet. Meanwhile, India shows reluctance in permitting UN access to conflict areas such as Kashmir. Additionally, the United States opposes the ICC’s jurisdiction over its nationals.
2. Selective Enforcement and Geopolitics
Moreover, powerful countries frequently shield their allies from accountability while condemning adversaries. For example, Western nations express concerns over Venezuela but often remain silent regarding Saudi Arabia’s human rights practices. Likewise, Russia and China have used their veto power in the UN Security Council to block resolutions against Syria and Myanmar.
3. Weak Enforcement Mechanisms
Furthermore, several human rights treaties lack robust enforcement mechanisms. The UNHRC can issue only recommendations, and the ICC relies heavily on cooperation from states to execute arrest warrants.
III. India’s Engagement with Human Rights and Global Governance
As the world’s largest democracy, India plays a complex role in the global human rights landscape. Although it has ratified key treaties, the implementation of these standards often proves inconsistent domestically.
1. Progress and Compliance
– The Indian Constitution includes protections that align with international benchmarks, notably through Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles.
– India actively participates in the UN Human Rights Council and contributes to discussions on international human rights.
– Moreover, recent progressive judicial rulings, such as the 2018 decriminalisation of homosexuality, highlight advancements in human rights.
2. Persistent Human Rights Challenges
Despite these legal protections, India faces significant human rights challenges, which include:
- Freedom of Expression and Dissent
– Authorities increasingly apply sedition laws (Section 124A of the IPC) against activists and journalists.
– Furthermore, India holds the record for global internet shutdowns, particularly in Kashmir.
– Non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs) also experience harassment under the Foreign Contribution Regulation Act (FCRA).
- Caste and Religious Discrimination
– Widespread violence against Dalits and minority communities persists, with incidents of lynching and hate speech often going unpunished.
- Conflict Zones and Security Laws
– In Kashmir, allegations of arbitrary detentions, torture, and media suppression are prevalent.
– Additionally, the Armed Forces Special Powers Act (AFSPA) grants immunity to security forces operating in conflict zones.
3. India’s Response to International Criticism
India frequently rebuffs UN reports, labelling them as “interference in internal affairs.” However, it engages constructively in multilateral forums aimed at fostering discussion and collaboration.
IV. Strengthening Human Rights Through Global Governance
1. Reforming International Institutions
To address political bias, we must enhance the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court (ICC) so that it can effectively tackle human rights violations without succumbing to the influence of powerful states. Additionally, we should render the recommendations of the United Nations Human Rights Council (UNHRC) obligatory, imposing clear repercussions for member states that fail to comply. Such measures could establish a more robust framework for accountability on the global stage.
2. Enhancing Domestic Accountability
We must empower National Human Rights Institutions (NHRIs) with greater independence, enabling them to advocate effectively for the rights of individuals within their jurisdictions. This empowerment could include judicial reforms aimed at speeding up the handling of human rights cases, ensuring that victims receive timely justice. By strengthening domestic accountability mechanisms, states can foster an environment where human rights exist not just on paper but are actively upheld.
3. Civil Society and Grassroots Movements
It is essential to protect human rights defenders from state persecution and repression. These individuals play a crucial role in advocating for the rights of marginalized communities. Therefore, encouraging solidarity among activists across national borders can amplify their efforts, fostering a unified front against oppression and injustice.
Conclusion: Towards a More Just Global Order
The intersection of human rights and global governance plays a pivotal role in addressing the myriad challenges of the 21st century, from authoritarian regimes to the pressing issue of climate justice. While international mechanisms provide a foundation for tackling these challenges, tangible progress relies on the willingness of states to comply, implement necessary reforms, and mobilize grassroots movements.
As an emerging global power, India possesses a unique opportunity to set a precedent by balancing sovereignty with accountability. Ensuring that domestic policies align with international commitments is crucial. Only through collaborative efforts can we aspire to build a world where human rights are genuinely universal and respected by all nations.
Also Read:
Rights of undertrial prisoners in India
How To Send A Legal Notice In India